Non Vanilla newbie game - Night Three - No lynch

[lord voldemort]

I knew I would pick the wrong one to watch last night. It was a toss up between Mandy and Kalish - I had a feeling Mandy was the Vig but thought they might target Kal anyway thinking he was it, or just because of his experience, but at the last minute I went with Mandy.

I had Jecko pegged as the GF and Lovo as scum (would never have guessed bomb though) and couldn't make my up between Frenchie and Militant.

Anyway good game Koesen. Thanks for all your time and effort. It was much appreciated.

how the hell did u have me as scum
no one did. i wasnt even mentioned at all

[suggs]

Thanks koesen. Definitely one of the best yet in Mafia.
Cop killing is fun

[Tripitaka]

I knew I would pick the wrong one to watch last night. It was a toss up between Mandy and Kalish - I had a feeling Mandy was the Vig but thought they might target Kal anyway thinking he was it, or just because of his experience, but at the last minute I went with Mandy.

I had Jecko pegged as the GF and Lovo as scum (would never have guessed bomb though) and couldn't make my up between Frenchie and Militant.

Anyway good game Koesen. Thanks for all your time and effort. It was much appreciated.

how the hell did u have me as scum
no one did. i wasnt even mentioned at all

Process of elimination for one, and just something about your posts - it started with your comments to Neo about using his ability and then how you subtly pushed for the lynch as the deadline approached but was careful not to be the hammer yourself - because either way would suit mafia. I didn't mention anything at the time though because obviously I didn't want to single myself out. I was hoping to get a bandwagon on Jecko Day 2 because even then I suspected him of being the GF and with him out of the way I could then use my cop investigation on you, but I was away for a few days and by the time I got back you'd already lynched Darth.

I very nearly included all my suspicions about you, Ga7 and Militant in the post I made before I claimed, but I thought it would be too much and again if I survived the lynch I didn't want to make myself an obvious target for the next night kill and besides I didn't have any real proof, just hunches and female intuition if you will.

[jecko7]

Bwa ha ha ha ha ha ha!

Kalishnikov dead tonight, that leaves 7, as long as there was a no lynch or town lynch we had this in the bag!

Good game everyone!

[Tripitaka]

Bwa ha ha ha ha ha ha!

Kalishnikov dead tonight, that leaves 7, as long as there was a no lynch or town lynch we had this in the bag!

Good game everyone!

Actually Mandy still had time to put her night action in so there is a chance she could have Vig killed Lovo or Ga7. So town weren't quite sunk, and I'm sure I could have persuaded the remaining townies to lynch you the next day.

But yes, good game.

[ga7]

Heheh. Nah I think we'd have managed a Militant lynch and the win easily seeing the last actions. Having the cops killed right away hurt the town a lot
It was pretty cool for a newbie game anyway, GG folks!

[mandyb]

I was aiming to kill you though Ga7. I think that may have changed things quite a lot. But, I guess we'll never know...

Sorry to hear you're leaving Koesen - thanks for the game and best of luck

[Koesen]

Militant, the elite bodyguard, was going to protect Ga7, so if you, Mandyb, tried to kill him, both you and militant would die, and that would result in an instant scum victory.

Usually scum wins when they are 50% of the remaining players, but as long as town had nightkill abilities too (and at least 50% of the survivors) I would have let the game go on, since there would still be a possibility that town killed all scum before scum killed all town.

But a ga7 hit would have been fatal.

Thanks again, all of you. It was my first and likely only time modding a game, and it was an interesting experience.

[kalishnikov]

It was an excellent game Koesen, thanks for having us. Hopefully things will work out for you and this won't be your last.

The scum definitly would have taken this, I was starting to get suspicious of lovo but wouldn't have brought it up today and would have been dead by tomorrow. The scum stayed hidden well and the town was clueless, a bad recipe for the town...

And to all you new players who were in this, well played. By far the best 'noob' game I've been in, very good job. I think a good majority of you guys have good mafia 'careers' ahead of you if you choose to keep playing. If any of you need a recommendation to get into a game (some mods require them for newer players) let me know and I'll gladly do it.