ah hang on, i see another question you should make your question clear, seems you asked two Question B why do you defend Tim over everything?
that is really very simple. I am convinced that you and streaker are scum, which is why i did not lynch cyan and why i am defending tim, if I am right then tim must be town.
But i tell you what, i will hammer tim tomorrow if no-one hammers streaker. I did say earlier that i would lynch an inactive, but i think lynching tim will take us forward, lynching cyan will not. if and when tim flips town you and streaker will be next and town will win.
Both claims are equal in strength. Tim IS playing his worst game on this site by a long way regardless of his alignment, and I am including the screenshot role game. This doesnt make him scum by itself.
So the problem with the Tim lynch is simple. If he flips mafia who is his scummate? I cant see anyone who would be. Bringing votes has been too easy. White Rose has defended Tim far too strongly to actually be his scumbuddy. This leaves only PTlowe or an inactive, and I just dont see PT as scum.
Streaker on the other hand I am open to the idea of Sausage or Pixar being his partner. At this point I see far more information coming from a Streaker lynch than a Tim lynch. With Tim all we really learn is his alignment. With Streaker there are a lot more standpoints to view with understanding of his alignment. Additionally, Streaker has actually been giving his reads on players unlike Tim.
Unvote Vote Streaker
Sorry, but town wont last another day without any information with which to work from. Dakky's lynch was uninformative. Tim's lynch would be uninformative. You've been echoing my actions all game and thats normally your scum tell.
Well done Tim, survived by being completely useless. (Read this as sarcasm.)
Hold on TWR I respect your protection of Tim that I cannot let you hammer him.I have been put in a bad posit ion and I honestly do not know who is scum, but TIM and Kratos did come after me and Streaker did not,and you got to admit Tims play has been weirder than usual , and come on who loses their character, s0 all I can do is UNVOTE VOTE TIM I hope I made the right choice ,
too late mitch, streaker has been lynched. wing just cos you hammered does not change my mind that you are his scum buddy. you were too afraid to lynch tim cos you know he will flip town, and then both you and streaker would be lynched one after the other, so you had no choice but to lynch your scum buddy.
if i die tonight, town you must not let wing fool you, he is streakers scum buddy and must be lynched tomorrow
wing, what happened to your theory that tim was the bus driver and i was his scum buddy? if you had thought for one tiny minute that was true you would have been happy for me to hammer tim,the only thing you could do was to unvote, but that would not be enough, with my double vote i could still have hammered tim, the only way you could stop me from hammering tim was to hammer your scum buddy. clearly you know perfectly well that he is town, to suggest who would be his scum buddy, could be anyone.....but you cannot afford for town to mislynch tim as it would be clear that you and streaker are scum together
soldier, this game is not open to sign ups, it has been played for several weeks now, however, if you would like to play mail the mod, we could do with a substitute to replace an inactive
WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:Both claims are equal in strength. Tim IS playing his worst game on this site by a long way regardless of his alignment, and I am including the screenshot role game. This doesnt make him scum by itself.
So the problem with the Tim lynch is simple. If he flips mafia who is his scummate? I cant see anyone who would be. Bringing votes has been too easy. White Rose has defended Tim far too strongly to actually be his scumbuddy. This leaves only PTlowe or an inactive, and I just dont see PT as scum.
Streaker on the other hand I am open to the idea of Sausage or Pixar being his partner. At this point I see far more information coming from a Streaker lynch than a Tim lynch. With Tim all we really learn is his alignment. With Streaker there are a lot more standpoints to view with understanding of his alignment. Additionally, Streaker has actually been giving his reads on players unlike Tim.
Unvote Vote Streaker
Sorry, but town wont last another day without any information with which to work from. Dakky's lynch was uninformative. Tim's lynch would be uninformative. You've been echoing my actions all game and thats normally your scum tell.
Well done Tim, survived by being completely useless. (Read this as sarcasm.)
I reading pixar as the other mafia. Sausage seems town this game. Mitch is playing a better game then normal...Well Tim is Tim.........I dont even know what to say about his play.
Do you want to know who you are? Don't ask. Act! Action will delineate and define you.
Thomas Jefferson
madmitch wrote:Hold on TWR I respect your protection of Tim that I cannot let you hammer him.I have been put in a bad posit ion and I honestly do not know who is scum, but TIM and Kratos did come after me and Streaker did not,and you got to admit Tims play has been weirder than usual , and come on who loses their character, s0 all I can do is UNVOTE VOTE TIM I hope I made the right choice ,
simple my inbox was full between clan mails, mafia,and those dang gide game mails... to lazy to check each box so i jsut click select all deleate selected.... actually i did it just again the other day and lost the character/role pm fr one of the other ones... i gotta figure out how to make a differant mailbox for mafia and guide and such
the white rose wrote:too late mitch, streaker has been lynched. wing just cos you hammered does not change my mind that you are his scum buddy. you were too afraid to lynch tim cos you know he will flip town, and then both you and streaker would be lynched one after the other, so you had no choice but to lynch your scum buddy.
if i die tonight, town you must not let wing fool you, he is streakers scum buddy and must be lynched tomorrow
Only Sausage or myself will be able to steer that game that way if your gone, maybe ragain.. Tim and mitch will circle for the next three centuries if we let them. Also I am fairly certain mafia will kill Mitch tonight anways. In the off chance they dont mitch...look at the most suspicious person to you
Do you want to know who you are? Don't ask. Act! Action will delineate and define you.
Thomas Jefferson
I read soldier's post as volunteering to be a replacement, but maybe I am just optimistic.
As for wing switching his vote... I can't say I am surprised. He has been trying to distance himself from streaker for a while, and now it finally built to this. It does seem a little strange in light of rose saying he would hammer tim. So many things about this switch scream scum, what rose said about him knowing tim would flip town not wanting to have to fight that (I do believe a lot of players in this game would base their votes tomorrow solely on today's flip). Also his listed reasoning really doesn't appear to make sense. He says we will get more info from streaker flipping scum than tim flipping scum. This statement has nothing to do with a read, and is basically stating that he is taking a risk. He is trying to justify leaving a player who has done nothing to aid the game and been a distraction recently to live while killing a player who has (in my opinion at least) been trying to help the town more (or at least trying to appear to). I am torn on this however. When I read through the first time, my thought was: "he is afraid tim will flip town, and streaker will flip scum and he doesn't want to be lynched this way". At first my mind said this was town because he thinks there is a chance streaker is scum and knows it would be a death sentence, but the more I think about it, a scum wing would make the same exact move, if not be even more likely to do it.
His reasoning just doesn't sit right with me. I think we should lynch the scummier player, not the player who if scum would give us more potential partner info. Maybe I am just against lynching a more helpful player because they are more helpful, it just seems backwards to me. It seems like scum trying to take advantage of an opportunity to off a player who may be asking the right questions.
I suppose he is correct though, we will know more once streaker's alignment is shown, although right now I don't think either alignment would look good on wing.
Hopefully streaker can post again before day end, even though he did give us his reads already.
So you guys decide to lynch me, one of the few who are actually scumhunting, over Tim, who has done absolutey nothing the entire game except cry and call me scum.
I don't know what else I should post. Remember my last post about my reads, and use it as you wish.
Official Vote Count
Timwoodbury(5)Wing,streaker,whatsausage,pixar,ragian
Streaker(5)Ptlowe,thewhiterose,madmitch,Timwoodbury,WingCmdr
Thats a lynch.
Streaker
Slime princess Vanilla Townie
Has been lynched.
N2 begins
Kratos/cyan will be replaced before D3 starts.
Deadline for NAs will be late sunday PM
White Rose - Reevalute without bias. Stop fitting evidence to your theory. Restructure your theory to new evidence. If Cyan and Kratos are modkilled we are going to be down to 7 players tomorrow, at which point you and tim only need 1 vote extra to lynch me. I am well aware that you two have completely failed to engage your brains and will vote me regardless of what i say or do so it has no effect on my actions.
Right now if Tim flips town what do we do? It doesnt prove anything about anyone. We start D3 with yet more arguments and I cannot face that again.
If Tim flips mafia what do we do? It doesnt prove anything about anyone. We start D3 with yet more arguments....
If Streaker flips town what do we do? We use his reads as a good starting point for discussion and look at how people have interacted with him. In this way we can play mafia rather than act like we at nursery.
If Streaker flips mafia what do we do? We use his reads and how people have interacted with him to start a discussion.
I've never been 100% on Tim being mafia. I started the case when I couldnt take the petty arguing anymore. My flip may not be the best thing for catching mafia. But it is 100% the best thing for my sanity. As I've said I am treating this as a beginners game and it is more important for players to learn than to try to win. We wont learn how to play mafia from lynching Tim.
HotShot53 replaces kratos644
Soldier4Christ replaces cyanineeter
There will be no more replacements,any other activity issues will be solved viaMODKILL
The one true hero and overall cool guy Finn the human
Madmitch
Town cop
Was found dead in his sleeping bag.
The candy kingdom swore they would avenge him at the end of a twizzler noose.
D3 begins.
With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.
[/quote]
