Moderator: Community Team
pancakemix wrote:Well, how many members of the Pirate Council do we think are likely. By nature of getting elected Pirate Queen, Elizabeth is by default a good candidate to be a Captain.
I agree with this - that lynch got us nowhere.got tonkaed wrote:This is why yesterday's speed lynch was stupid. There was no reason to miss out on an entire day of discussion regarding who the recruiter might be or to have failed to get a name out of edoc.
Id still argue that edoc should have to put a name forward as otherwise, he is the safest lynch. Having said that, it is probably equally as important to find where the recruiter might come from.
I would prefer to actually go against our lovely cult leader, but if I'm being honest, I only have a couple of suspicions who it could be and they really don't have any factual basis.edocsil wrote:
I am happy to give another name if we are going to hang him, but you can understand why I have no real desire to give you a name for a NK, it defeats the purpose of my gamble. If you would like to scum hunt for Jones I would be happy to help, and if the day drags out I would be willing to give you a name then for a lynch. Your guy's call.
And please do not forget that he was one of the quick hammerers a bit before as well along with his behaviour. I will gladly 2nd this and yet again vote for Mandy.nagerous wrote:Before we got distracted with all this lynching mafia business, my suspicions would still be on mandy.
Got tonkaed raised a good point at the end of the day phase, that we shouldn't speed lynch and mandy's response was just to mindlessly bandwagon. The next post was by Saxlad dropping the hammer. Now I expect that from Sax as he is more inexperienced at mafia but for mandy just to show in and vote sends me a message that he wanted to end the day quickly, thus further strengthening an already expanding cult.
Now it seems to me that we should definitely aim at lynching Davey Jones today and whilst I would love a name from edocsil, if that is not going to be our priority in the lynch it seems he won't give us one.. I therefore formally accuse mandy of being the cult leader.
Vote Mandy
There was also that Asian Pirate ship with the captain, but I'm not completely sure if that's significant enough. There were some minor captains, but I don't think they're in the game. Personally, I think these are great news!freezie wrote:Anyway, back on my claim. I got 1 positive result out of all, and it's a 50% chance ( unless I forgot one ) that I find Jack ( Edoc's target, good for us..and slightly for town ) Or Davy Jones, our big winner.
I won't tell who I found captainish right now. I will wait in case I forgot 6-7 captains and be completly off the track. But..yea. 50-50 on Davy jones..Or helping edoc :S
To be fair, if you would re-read, I'm fairly sure you could easily notice who is Elizabeth.freezie wrote: Wait, my role pm says any captains of a ship AT ANY POINTS in the movie..
And I am 99% I haven't found Elizabeth anyway XD
But was she the captain of a ship ( Though you could be right as I vaguelly remember her beeing a ''captain'' in the third movie....
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
Since you already claimed, would you mind to fully revealing your name and roll? As far as the naming goes, I'm totally fine with it as long as it's not Elizabeth. As for now, I'll keep my vote on the most suspicious person I see - Mandy.edocsil wrote:Well, you should claim who you found then and assuming it isn't Liz(I am with Com on this one), we should hang them. If it is Davey, it's good for all of us, it ends the cults threat and then I know the identity of the reaming scum, which I will give when you need them. If it is Jack, we hang him and after his death I give you all the remaining scum. What say you?
BTW I am the Asian captain
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
Commander9 wrote:To be fair, if you would re-read, I'm fairly sure you could easily notice who is Elizabeth.
If it's Jack, he won't tell us he's Jack. And we can't be sure of your status after Jack's death (unless I missed something). Freezie, I'm assuming you just get a yea or nay on the character?edocsil wrote:Well, you should claim who you found then and assuming it isn't Liz(I am with Com on this one), we should hang them. If it is Davey, it's good for all of us, it ends the cults threat and then I know the identity of the reaming scum, which I will give when you need them. If it is Jack, we hang him and after his death I give you all the remaining scum. What say you?
BTW I am the Asian captain
aage wrote:Never trust CYOC or pancake.
pancakemix wrote:If it's Jack, he won't tell us he's Jack. And we can't be sure of your status after Jack's death (unless I missed something). Freezie, I'm assuming you just get a yea or nay on the character?edocsil wrote:Well, you should claim who you found then and assuming it isn't Liz(I am with Com on this one), we should hang them. If it is Davey, it's good for all of us, it ends the cults threat and then I know the identity of the reaming scum, which I will give when you need them. If it is Jack, we hang him and after his death I give you all the remaining scum. What say you?
BTW I am the Asian captain
Apologies - forgot that.strike wolf wrote:Edoc gave his full name day 2.
It's yay from me then.freezie wrote:Alright, I'll re-phrase
I am 150% sure it's not Liz that I found.
I followed the game..I know it's not her.
But he would have to explain why he had a ship, and all the current candidates would lie. so the point is kinda moot.pancakemix wrote:If it's Jack, he won't tell us he's Jack. And we can't be sure of your status after Jack's death (unless I missed something). Freezie, I'm assuming you just get a yea or nay on the character?edocsil wrote:Well, you should claim who you found then and assuming it isn't Liz(I am with Com on this one), we should hang them. If it is Davey, it's good for all of us, it ends the cults threat and then I know the identity of the reaming scum, which I will give when you need them. If it is Jack, we hang him and after his death I give you all the remaining scum. What say you?
BTW I am the Asian captain
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
I would help some who helps me, that's how I do things.strike wolf wrote:Ok I took some time to consider the evidence and the night 2 lynch and everything going on. First I agree at this point cult is by far the biggest threat. Second I think at this point you should say who it was you caught freezie. Also we should be wary about lynching jack as that will be the end of edoc's help with finding mafia and he's likely to have a pretty good role. I had more to say but honestly I'm peeking at this thread over a project and can't remember what it was.
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
And you have confirmed with safari that you would not be end gamed?edocsil wrote:I would help some who helps me, that's how I do things.strike wolf wrote:Ok I took some time to consider the evidence and the night 2 lynch and everything going on. First I agree at this point cult is by far the biggest threat. Second I think at this point you should say who it was you caught freezie. Also we should be wary about lynching jack as that will be the end of edoc's help with finding mafia and he's likely to have a pretty good role. I had more to say but honestly I'm peeking at this thread over a project and can't remember what it was.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
Well in truth we have more on him than that. Rushing two lynches day 1 and later day 3. Overall suspicious behavior regarding the falco and fircoal cases day 1. Very defensive and out of character behavior. Etc.freezie wrote:Well, whatever, at this point, I will spill the beans.
Strike wolf is NOT a captain.
Commander is NOT a captain.
And you will all be happy to know MANDY is a captain.
But he has a few votes already, and lynching him just for that would be ridiculus....Let's hear him now.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
And I can also confirm I'm no captain.freezie wrote:Well, whatever, at this point, I will spill the beans.
Strike wolf is NOT a captain.
Commander is NOT a captain.
And you will all be happy to know MANDY is a captain.
But he has a few votes already, and lynching him just for that would be ridiculus....Let's hear him now.
strike wolf wrote:Well in truth we have more on him than that. Rushing two lynches day 1 and later day 3. Overall suspicious behavior regarding the falco and fircoal cases day 1. Very defensive and out of character behavior. Etc.freezie wrote:Well, whatever, at this point, I will spill the beans.
Strike wolf is NOT a captain.
Commander is NOT a captain.
And you will all be happy to know MANDY is a captain.
But he has a few votes already, and lynching him just for that would be ridiculus....Let's hear him now.
I can confirm I am not a captain.
Yes. Had to read between the lines a bit, but I will not be killed if I win. More then that I would need to ask to say.strike wolf wrote:And you have confirmed with safari that you would not be end gamed?edocsil wrote:I would help some who helps me, that's how I do things.strike wolf wrote:Ok I took some time to consider the evidence and the night 2 lynch and everything going on. First I agree at this point cult is by far the biggest threat. Second I think at this point you should say who it was you caught freezie. Also we should be wary about lynching jack as that will be the end of edoc's help with finding mafia and he's likely to have a pretty good role. I had more to say but honestly I'm peeking at this thread over a project and can't remember what it was.
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
If I was a Cult Leader you and Tonka would be my first recruits. Thus, if you want to find out for sure if I'm a Cult Leader or not, I propose that we lynch you and, if you have been recruited, this would definitely point towards me as Cult leader, and I would then be prepared to claim, which should prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that I am in fact not the Cult Leader. Savvy?nagerous wrote:Before we got distracted with all this lynching mafia business, my suspicions would still be on mandy.
Got tonkaed raised a good point at the end of the day phase, that we shouldn't speed lynch and mandy's response was just to mindlessly bandwagon. The next post was by Saxlad dropping the hammer. Now I expect that from Sax as he is more inexperienced at mafia but for mandy just to show in and vote sends me a message that he wanted to end the day quickly, thus further strengthening an already expanding cult.
Now it seems to me that we should definitely aim at lynching Davey Jones today and whilst I would love a name from edocsil, if that is not going to be our priority in the lynch it seems he won't give us one.. I therefore formally accuse mandy of being the cult leader.
Vote Mandy
Talapus wrote: I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
Talapus wrote: I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
aage wrote:Never trust CYOC or pancake.
Qft. vote mandypancakemix wrote:Vote Mandy for that total nonsense argument and lack of any real response to freezie's claim.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
); do you b) want another name from Edoc, lynch that person and have Mafia waste their NK on me. Edoc should not have problem with the latter scenario, unless he explicitly wants to win with his Mafia or do you c) want to find Davey Jones who I certainly am not.Talapus wrote: I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
