Detailed Map Statistics (Update: 4 June 08) COMPLETE

[TaCktiX]

DISCLAIMER: All stats are compiled by myself. In the case of Feedback/Support/Spam, it is PURELY subjective. These are to be used as reference material, not as statistical gospel.

Source File located at: http://www.sendspace.com/file/f1l2mh For all the people who want to compare stats side by side with ease. INCLUDES Map Health, which is presently not working properly. Got a few higher priorities, like updating the stats.

Present Updates:
Advanced Ideas: 4 June 08
Active Foundry: 29 May 08
Final Forge: 4 June 08

Categories:
Advanced Ideas
Active Foundry (last reply within a week)
Final Forge

Criteria:
Total Replies
Replies since last posted Revision
Number of posts made by Creator
Number of posts made by Cartography Assistants
Number of Feedback posts
Number of Support posts

Derived Statistics:
Posts/day (since topic start)
Posts/day (since last revision)
Number of posts made by Others
Percentage of posts by Creator
Percentage of posts by Cartography Assistants
Percentage of posts by Others
Number of Spam posts
Percentage of Feedback posts
Percentage of Support posts
Percentage of Spam posts

Clarifying Definitions of Subjective Criteria:
Feedback: Anything relating to the map with specific things mentioned about the map. This can be criticism, approval of a change, suggestion of further additions, etc.
Support: Generic reference to the map, it being "good", "can't wait to play", etc. Nothing specific is mentioned about the map proper.
Spam: Anything not relating to the map (i.e., not Feedback or Support)

Specific Post Types and How I Evaluate Them:
Feedback:
- Poll Results
Support:
- Stamps
- Anything referencing the next Stage in development for the map (stamp it, quench it, move it to Foundry)

[TaCktiX]

Advanced Ideas (Stage II)

Name: Allegheny Forest, PA, USA
Creator: seamusk
Starting Date: May 19th, 2008
Last Revision Date: June 4th, 2008
Posts: 89
Posts since Last Revision: 7
Posts/day: 5.56
Posts/day since Last Revision: 7.0

Posts by Creator: 40 (44.94%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 10 (11.24%)
Posts by Others: 39 (43.82%)

Posts not by Creator: 49
Feedback Posts: 30 (61.22%)
Support Posts: 3 (6.12%)
Spam Posts: 16 (32.65%)

Name: Castle Battle
Creators: Marvaddin and Telvannia
Starting Date: May 26th, 2008
Last Revision Date: June 3rd, 2008
Posts: 52
Posts since Last Revision: 6
Posts/day: 5.78
Posts/day since Last Revision: 6.0

Posts by Creators: 10 (19.23%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 4 (7.69%)
Posts by Others: 38 (73.08%)

Posts not by Creators: 42
Feedback Posts: 35 (83.33%)
Support Posts: 4 (9.52%)
Spam Posts: 3 (7.14%)

Name: Los Angeles
Creator: oaktown
Starting Date: May 11th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 27th, 2008
Posts: 65
Posts since Last Revision: 13
Posts/day: 2.71
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.63

Posts by Creator: 15 (23.08%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 1 (1.54%)
Posts by Others: 49 (75.38%)

Posts not by Creator: 50
Feedback Posts: 38 (76.0%)
Support Posts: 4 (8.0%)
Spam Posts: 8 (16.0%)

Name: Nubian Egypt
Creator: cairnswk
Starting Date: April 25th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 18th, 2008
Posts: 73
Posts since Last Revision: 8
Posts/day: 1.83
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.47

Posts by Creator: 32 (43.84%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 6 (8.22%)
Posts by Others: 35 (47.95%)

Posts not by Creator: 41
Feedback Posts: 32 (78.05%)
Support Posts: 2 (4.88%)
Spam Posts: 7 (17.07%)

Name: The Era of the Three Kingdoms
Creator: gimil
Starting Date: May 22nd, 2008
Last Revision Date: June 4th, 2008
Posts: 76
Posts since Last Revision: 1
Posts/day: 5.85
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.0

Posts by Creator: 19 (25.0%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 5 (6.58%)
Posts by Others: 52 (68.42%)

Posts not by Creator: 57
Feedback Posts: 47 (82.46%)
Support Posts: 1 (1.75%)
Spam Posts: 9 (15.79%)

[TaCktiX]

Active Foundry (Stage III)

Name: Archipelago
Creators: Mjinga and ZeakCytho
Starting Date: April 6th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 11th, 2008
Posts: 218
Posts since Last Revision: 22
Posts/day: 4.11
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.22

Posts by Creators: 69 (31.65%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 6 (2.75%)
Posts by Others: 143 (65.6%)

Posts not by Creators: 149
Feedback Posts: 110 (73.83%)
Support Posts: 9 (6.04%)
Spam Posts: 30 (20.13%)

Name: Charleston SC
Creator: RjBeals
Starting Date: May 15th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 27th, 2008
Posts: 87
Posts since Last Revision: 7
Posts/day: 6.21
Posts/day since Last Revision: 3.5

Posts by Creator: 22 (25.29%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 14 (16.09%)
Posts by Others: 51 (58.62%)

Posts not by Creator: 65
Feedback Posts: 45 (69.23%)
Support Posts: 8 (12.31%)
Spam Posts: 12 (18.46%)

Name: Conquer 4
Creators: yeti_c and gimil
Starting Date: May 15th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 18th, 2008
Posts: 78
Posts since Last Revision: 5
Posts/day: 5.57
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.45

Posts by Creators: 36 (46.15%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 3 (3.85%)
Posts by Others: 39 (50.0%)

Posts not by Creators: 42
Feedback Posts: 34 (80.95%)
Support Posts: 4 (9.52%)
Spam Posts: 4 (9.52%)

Name: Cyprus
Creator: Ruben Cassar
Starting Date: April 28th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 23rd, 2008
Posts: 104
Posts since Last Revision: 23
Posts/day: 3.35
Posts/day since Last Revision: 3.83

Posts by Creator: 40 (38.46%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 11 (10.58%)
Posts by Others: 53 (50.96%)

Posts not by Creator: 64
Feedback Posts: 48 (75.0%)
Support Posts: 6 (9.38%)
Spam Posts: 10 (15.63%)

Name: Dark Age Britain
Creators: Telvannia and Balsiefen
Starting Date: December 13th, 2007
Last Revision Date: May 19th, 2008
Posts: 230
Posts since Last Revision: 6
Posts/day: 1.37
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.6

Posts by Creators: 85 (36.96%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 47 (20.43%)
Posts by Others: 98 (42.61%)

Posts not by Creators: 145
Feedback Posts: 98 (67.59%)
Support Posts: 9 (6.21%)
Spam Posts: 38 (26.21%)

Name: Empire Builder
Creator: bryguy
Starting Date: January 13th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 23rd, 2008
Posts: 358
Posts since Last Revision: 3
Posts/day: 2.61
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.5

Posts by Creator: 170 (47.49%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 20 (5.59%)
Posts by Others: 168 (46.93%)

Posts not by Creator: 188
Feedback Posts: 135 (71.81%)
Support Posts: 11 (5.85%)
Spam Posts: 42 (22.34%)

Name: France 18th Century
Creator: pamoa
Starting Date: May 3rd, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 10th, 2008
Posts: 69
Posts since Last Revision: 40
Posts/day: 2.65
Posts/day since Last Revision: 2.11

Posts by Creator: 16 (23.19%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 6 (8.7%)
Posts by Others: 47 (68.12%)

Posts not by Creator: 53
Feedback Posts: 38 (71.7%)
Support Posts: 7 (13.21%)
Spam Posts: 8 (15.09%)

Name: Holy Roman Empire
Creators: grayhawke Unit_2 and pamoa
Starting Date: January 4th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 19th, 2008
Posts: 169
Posts since Last Revision: 14
Posts/day: 1.16
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.4

Posts by Creators: 74 (43.79%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 10 (5.92%)
Posts by Others: 85 (50.3%)

Posts not by Creators: 95
Feedback Posts: 64 (67.37%)
Support Posts: 10 (10.53%)
Spam Posts: 21 (22.11%)

Name: Imperium Romanum
Creator: qwert
Starting Date: January 28th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 16th, 2008
Posts: 267
Posts since Last Revision: 38
Posts/day: 2.19
Posts/day since Last Revision: 2.92

Posts by Creator: 124 (46.44%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 31 (11.61%)
Posts by Others: 112 (41.95%)

Posts not by Creator: 143
Feedback Posts: 69 (48.25%)
Support Posts: 17 (11.89%)
Spam Posts: 57 (39.86%)

Name: Madagascar
Creator: t-o-m
Starting Date: April 19th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 29th, 2008
Posts: 297
Posts since Last Revision: 12
Posts/day: 7.43
Posts/day since Last Revision: 12.0

Posts by Creator: 121 (40.74%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 19 (6.4%)
Posts by Others: 157 (52.86%)

Posts not by Creator: 176
Feedback Posts: 128 (72.73%)
Support Posts: 11 (6.25%)
Spam Posts: 37 (21.02%)

Name: Mexico
Creators: fumandomuerte
Starting Date: February 1st, 2008
Last Revision Date: March 17th, 2008
Posts: 72
Posts since Last Revision: 24
Posts/day: 0.61
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.33

Posts by Creators: 12 (16.67%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 7 (9.72%)
Posts by Others: 53 (73.61%)

Posts not by Creators: 60
Feedback Posts: 37 (61.67%)
Support Posts: 10 (16.67%)
Spam Posts: 13 (21.67%)

Name: New Europe
Creator: MrBenn
Starting Date: December 30th, 2007
Last Revision Date: May 4th, 2008
Posts: 426
Posts since Last Revision: 14
Posts/day: 2.82
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.56

Posts by Creator: 114 (26.76%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 49 (11.5%)
Posts by Others: 220 (51.64%)

Posts not by Creator: 312
Feedback Posts: 208 (66.67%)
Support Posts: 9 (2.88%)
Spam Posts: 95 (30.45%)

Name: Oasis
Creator: wcaclimbing
Starting Date: February 17th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 16th, 2008
Posts: 494
Posts since Last Revision: 35
Posts/day: 4.84
Posts/day since Last Revision: 2.69

Posts by Creator: 120 (24.29%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 48 (9.72%)
Posts by Others: 326 (65.99%)

Posts not by Creator: 374
Feedback Posts: 223 (59.63%)
Support Posts: 40 (10.7%)
Spam Posts: 111 (29.68%)

Name: Periodic Madness
Creators: shadowsteel9 and TaCktiX
Starting Date: March 22nd, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 27th, 2008
Posts: 193
Posts since Last Revision: 10
Posts/day: 2.84
Posts/day since Last Revision: 5.0

Posts by Creators: 82 (42.49%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 8 (4.15%)
Posts by Others: 103 (53.37%)

Posts not by Creators: 111
Feedback Posts: 72 (64.86%)
Support Posts: 10 (9.01%)
Spam Posts: 29 (26.13%)

Name: Poker Map
Creators: yeti_c WidowMakers and Coleman
Starting Date: July 6th, 2007
Last Revision Date: May 5th, 2008
Posts: 159
Posts since Last Revision: 29
Posts/day: 0.48
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.21

Posts by Creators: 67 (42.14%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 9 (5.66%)
Posts by Others: 83 (52.2%)

Posts not by Creators: 92
Feedback Posts: 62 (67.39%)
Support Posts: 13 (14.13%)
Spam Posts: 17 (18.48%)

Name: Switzerland
Creator: Kaplowitz
Starting Date: April 4th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 12th, 2008
Posts: 231
Posts since Last Revision: 45
Posts/day: 4.2
Posts/day since Last Revision: 2.65

Posts by Creator: 82 (35.5%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 11 (4.76%)
Posts by Others: 138 (59.74%)

Posts not by Creator: 149
Feedback Posts: 112 (75.17%)
Support Posts: 14 (9.4%)
Spam Posts: 23 (15.44%)

Name: The Citadel
Creator: TaCktiX
Starting Date: January 24th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 20th, 2008
Posts: 217
Posts since Last Revision: 22
Posts/day: 1.72
Posts/day since Last Revision: 2.44

Posts by Creator: 71 (32.72%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 18 (8.29%)
Posts by Others: 128 (58.99%)

Posts not by Creator: 146
Feedback Posts: 84 (57.53%)
Support Posts: 24 (16.44%)
Spam Posts: 38 (26.03%)

Active Foundry (Stage IV)

Name: Germany Revamp
Creator: pepperonibread
Starting Date: March 22nd, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 5th, 2008
Posts: 105
Posts since Last Revision: 17
Posts/day: 1.54
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.71

Posts by Creator: 31 (29.52%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 12 (11.43%)
Posts by Others: 62 (59.05%)

Posts not by Creator: 74
Feedback Posts: 54 (72.97%)
Support Posts: 7 (9.46%)
Spam Posts: 13 (17.57%)

Name: Maze Craze
Creators: WidowMakers and yeti_c
Starting Date: March 16th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 18th, 2008
Posts: 258
Posts since Last Revision: 20
Posts/day: 3.49
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.82

Posts by Creators: 82 (31.78%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 21 (8.14%)
Posts by Others: 155 (60.08%)

Posts not by Creators: 176
Feedback Posts: 116 (65.91%)
Support Posts: 9 (5.11%)
Spam Posts: 51 (28.98%)

Active Foundry (Stage V)

Name: CC Archery
Creators: Kaplowitz and gimil
Starting Date: December 12th, 2007
Last Revision Date: May 23rd, 2008
Posts: 324
Posts since Last Revision: 27
Posts/day: 1.92
Posts/day since Last Revision: 4.5

Posts by Creators: 157 (48.46%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 29 (8.95%)
Posts by Others: 138 (42.59%)

Posts not by Creators: 167
Feedback Posts: 107 (64.07%)
Support Posts: 9 (5.39%)
Spam Posts: 51 (30.54%)

Name: Luxembourg
Creator: Ruben Cassar
Starting Date: April 20th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 23rd, 2008
Posts: 170
Posts since Last Revision: 21
Posts/day: 4.36
Posts/day since Last Revision: 3.5

Posts by Creator: 64 (37.65%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 17 (10.0%)
Posts by Others: 89 (52.35%)

Posts not by Creator: 106
Feedback Posts: 71 (66.98%)
Support Posts: 17 (16.04%)
Spam Posts: 18 (16.98%)

Name: San Marino
Creator: Ruben Cassar
Starting Date: April 16th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 15th, 2008
Posts: 214
Posts since Last Revision: 23
Posts/day: 4.98
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.64

Posts by Creator: 101 (47.2%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 29 (13.55%)
Posts by Others: 84 (39.25%)

Posts not by Creator: 113
Feedback Posts: 92 (81.42%)
Support Posts: 13 (11.5%)
Spam Posts: 8 (7.08%)

Name: Upper Egypt
Creator: cairnswk
Starting Date: April 7th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 24th, 2008
Posts: 137
Posts since Last Revision: 3
Posts/day: 2.63
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.6

Posts by Creator: 63 (45.99%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 13 (9.49%)
Posts by Others: 61 (44.53%)

Posts not by Creator: 74
Feedback Posts: 53 (71.62%)
Support Posts: 7 (9.46%)
Spam Posts: 14 (18.92%)

[TaCktiX]

Final Forge (Stage VI)

Name: CC City Mogul
Creator: DiM
Starting Date: January 14th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 4th, 2008
Posts: 433
Posts since Last Revision: 14
Posts/day: 3.05
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.45

Posts by Creator: 190 (43.88%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 55 (12.7%)
Posts by Others: 188 (43.42%)

Posts not by Creator: 243
Feedback Posts: 105 (43.21%)
Support Posts: 35 (14.4%)
Spam Posts: 103 (42.39%)

Name: Golfe du St-Laurent
Creators: Lone.prophet and Unit_2
Starting Date: January 10th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 11th, 2008
Posts: 375
Posts since Last Revision: 38
Posts/day: 2.57
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.58

Posts by Creators: 178 (47.47%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 43 (11.47%)
Posts by Others: 154 (41.07%)

Posts not by Creators: 197
Feedback Posts: 128 (64.97%)
Support Posts: 17 (8.63%)
Spam Posts: 52 (26.4%)

Name: Lower Egypt
Creator: cairnswk
Starting Date: March 14th, 2008
Last Revision Date: June 4th, 2008
Posts: 221
Posts since Last Revision: 1
Posts/day: 2.7
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.0

Posts by Creator: 105 (47.51%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 27 (12.22%)
Posts by Others: 89 (40.27%)

Posts not by Creator: 116
Feedback Posts: 85 (73.28%)
Support Posts: 15 (12.93%)
Spam Posts: 16 (13.79%)

Name: Operation Drug War
Creators: Edbeard Telvannia and zimmah
Starting Date: December 18th, 2007
Last Revision Date: May 15th, 2008
Posts: 191
Posts since Last Revision: 3
Posts/day: 1.13
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.15

Posts by Creators: 70 (36.65%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 37 (19.37%)
Posts by Others: 84 (43.98%)

Posts not by Creators: 121
Feedback Posts: 57 (47.11%)
Support Posts: 18 (14.88%)
Spam Posts: 46 (38.02%)

Name: Supermax: Prison Riot
Creators: mibi and Coleman
Starting Date: June 6th, 2007
Last Revision Date: May 30th, 2008
Posts: 672
Posts since Last Revision: 7
Posts/day: 2.01
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.4

Posts by Creators: 235 (34.97%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 53 (7.89%)
Posts by Others: 384 (57.14%)

Posts not by Creators: 437
Feedback Posts: 198 (45.31%)
Support Posts: 48 (10.98%)
Spam Posts: 191 (43.71%)

Name: Sydney Metro
Creator: cairnswk
Starting Date: March 29th, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 16th, 2008
Posts: 181
Posts since Last Revision: 7
Posts/day: 2.7
Posts/day since Last Revision: 0.37

Posts by Creator: 77 (42.54%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 24 (13.26%)
Posts by Others: 80 (44.2%)

Posts not by Creator: 104
Feedback Posts: 66 (63.46%)
Support Posts: 15 (14.42%)
Spam Posts: 23 (22.12%)

Final Forge (Stage VII)

Name: British Isles Revamp
Creators: gimil and lanyards
Starting Date: December 4th, 2007
Last Revision Date: April 30th, 2008
Posts: 646
Posts since Last Revision: 49
Posts/day: 3.55
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.4

Posts by Creators: 203 (31.42%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 25 (3.87%)
Posts by Others: 418 (64.71%)

Posts not by Creators: 443
Feedback Posts: 255 (57.56%)
Support Posts: 33 (7.45%)
Spam Posts: 155 (34.99%)

Name: Treasures of Galapagos
Creator: cairnswk
Starting Date: January 23rd, 2008
Last Revision Date: May 23rd, 2008
Posts: 294
Posts since Last Revision: 23
Posts/day: 2.21
Posts/day since Last Revision: 1.92

Posts by Creator: 133 (45.24%)
Posts by Cartography Assistants: 26 (8.84%)
Posts by Others: 135 (45.92%)

Posts not by Creator: 161
Feedback Posts: 105 (65.22%)
Support Posts: 17 (10.56%)
Spam Posts: 39 (24.22%)

[DiM]

one small request, could you make the map names as links to the threads?

perhaps people see a map is in need of support according to the stats and a quick link there would help them go fast and add a comment.

[wcaclimbing]

*waits to see Oasis stats*

I don't see how you have enough free time to compile all of this information.....
Good luck!

[TaCktiX]

Map Links added to the 4 topics stat'ed right now. I'll update by next Friday on the Advanced Ideas.

As for Active Foundry, I will work on the 20-odd topics tomorrow (two day delay, for I was working on Advanced Ideas Thursday night). Putting the initial statistics in is time-consuming, but updating stats won't be that hard.

Final Forge will be worked on on Monday (two day delay, again). That way I don't need to worry about a statistics glut on one day of the week. I'm going to try to update categories in one big batch so that topics of the same type can be compared without worrying about date of compilation.

[TaCktiX]

Additions:
Repubblica di San Marino
New Europe
CC Archery
Sydney Metro
Feudal War Revamp

Updates:
Switzerland
Panama
The Citadel
Holy Roman Empire

[InkL0sed]

This is so great Tack, keep it up.

[fireedud]

I don't see how you have enough free time to compile all of this information.....
Good luck!

This is so great Tack, keep it up.

[TaCktiX]

Additions
Periodic Madness
Treasures of Galapagos
Lanyards' Brazil
Mexico
Indian Subcontinent

Updates
The Citadel
Repubblica di San Marino
Switzerland
New Europe

[InkL0sed]

You have a minor problem with the bbCode, Tack; Indian Subcontinent is completely in bold.

[TaCktiX]

Fixed. Thanks for the point, I likely wouldn't have noticed until tomorrow when I add some more.

[Kaplowitz]

This should be stickied, and maybe you could add little descriptions like Coleman's Foundry News.

[oaktown]

i agree that this is very cool... some free time on your hands this weekend, Tack?

[TaCktiX]

It's not the only thing I did this weekend, just look at The Citadel version 8. Yeah, proud of that one.

As for the stats, I'm going to keep on trying to add 4-5 maps from Active Foundry each day until they're all up, and update whatever I've already compiled. Really, the b**** is in the first compilation, updating is just a matter of adding a few posts to the statistics. When Active Foundry is done I'll do Final Forge. Once I've gotten everything added, I will update once weekly, likely on Friday or Saturday.

[bryguy]

It's not the only thing I did this weekend, just look at The Citadel version 8. Yeah, proud of that one.

As for the stats, I'm going to keep on trying to add 4-5 maps from Active Foundry each day until they're all up, and update whatever I've already compiled. Really, the b**** is in the first compilation, updating is just a matter of adding a few posts to the statistics. When Active Foundry is done I'll do Final Forge. Once I've gotten everything added, I will update once weekly, likely on Friday or Saturday.

how long till empire builder?

btw, for some reason ur sig lost a few maps....

[TaCktiX]

I'm going in roughly reverse activity order. In other words, the longer it's been since the last post, the earlier I get to it. Empire Builder keeps on getting posts, so I'm holding off on it, because I don't want to be compiling stats and then someone posts again. THAT'S a pain.

[bryguy]

i did an advanced search for empire builder and my posts in it just to help u out a little

for Empire Builder, I (the author) have 36-38 posts out of 294

edit: so basically i have 13% of the posts..... wow

edit2: btw u actually might want to do empire builder while nobodies posting, cause in a couple days im gonna post an update, and then its gonna get busy again

[RjBeals]

Are you actually scrolling through the entire thread and counting out all these posts? Jeez...

I wonder if there's a way to dump this info from the phpbb db, then run some macro's or pivot tables to create this.

[bryguy]

Are you actually scrolling through the entire thread and counting out all these posts? Jeez...

I wonder if there's a way to dump this info from the phpbb db, then run some macro's or pivot tables to create this.

i didnt, i used advanced search, put in the keyword empire builder, and put the author bryguy

then i counted out the results that were from my topic

[TaCktiX]

To answer your question, Rj, yes I am. Call me crazy, but it really doesn't take that long to do it with the creator, and while I'm scanning the topic 4-5 odd times I pick up a lot of information that's not shown on the stats. By the time I'm done with this, I'll likely know map development better than the C.A.s.

[wcaclimbing]

Oasis's discussions have died down quite a bit (Its getting near the bottom of the page, no posts for almost 24 hours)
This would be a good time to do Oasis's stats, before I put up my next update in a few days.

[TaCktiX]

wcaclimbing, I actually prefer compiling statistics on a map following a recent revision. It helps show the spike in posting that revisions cause (case in point both of my maps, 20 posts on The Citadel in a day, almost the same for Periodic Madness in less time), displaying interest better than the posts/day itself.

bryguy, I completed Empire Builder's statistics, and here's my breakdown looking over it. Early on you had a TIME getting feedback, as a lot of people were busy spamming "zomg, Feudal War clone, only crappier graphics!" I was over halfway through the topic and you had less than 40% Feedback. Fortunately your graphics overhaul did wonders for map interest and feedback went flying upward. It's at 68.99%, one of the higher percentages thus far. You've also gotten a pretty substantial amount of CA support on your map, getting 6.08%. Gimil has been trying a lot to help your map succeed, be thankful. One thing that's a problem is how much you post: 46.62% of the time. No other single mapmaker has you beat for that statistic. Several of your posts were in retort to the Feudal War clone spam, and later on you've had a lot of short double and triple posts when one post would suffice. In sum, your map is doing above average compared to the rest I have so far.

Updates: Note: From now on, if all I did was edit the posts/day counts, I don't consider them updated, though they were
Switzerland
The Citadel MOVED to Active Foundry
Repubblica di San Marino MOVED to Active Foundry
New Europe
Sydney Metro
Feudal War Revamp
Periodic Madness
Indian Subcontinent
Treasures of Galapagos

Additions:
Dark Age Britain
Empire Builder

[TaCktiX]

Removed due to Inactivity
Panama
CC Archery

Additions
SUPERMAX: Prison Riot
Germany Revamp
Upper Egypt

Updates:
Holy Roman Empire
Switzerland
The Citadel
Repubblica di San Marino
New Europe
Sydney Metro
Dark Age Britain
Empire Builder
Periodic Madness
Indian Subcontinent