idk, 24 hours, 36 maybe?
Moderator: Community Team
TX AG 90 wrote:blacky365 wrote:TX AG 90 wrote:blacky,
You say your N1 result was "No Result". Was it worded like that or was it that you never got a chance to perform your night action because you were poisoned 1st?
The response was as I described earlier... I could see my target in the distance and as I was swimming towards it I felt a pain on the side and I was poisoned.
Ok, that's different than No Result. You never got to perform your action.
Skoffin wrote:Lol if everyone gets possibly 38 hours to answer we'll literally run out the clock
also I'm not a joker
Ragian wrote:I have several bonuses. Weirdly, my win condition isn't in my role pm
Ragian wrote:I have several bonuses. Weirdly, my win condition isn't in my role pm
Ragian wrote:I have several bonuses. Weirdly, my win condition isn't in my role pm
I still don't like that answer. Because it's not an answer.TX AG 90 wrote:Pikanchion wrote:Sirius Kase wrote:So, we have Pika wiretapper and Blacky the maybe cop. Who do we trust?
Why not trust aage, the confirmed Town?
It's not about trusting aage, it's just without knowing WHY aage thought BJ was town, we don't know if he was mistaken or not (and he's too dead to ask). There have been tons of incorrect assumptions made so far and that could have been one of them.
Someone mentioned that scum may have targeted aage that night because he misaligned BJ and they wanted to lock in the dying man's last words as a misdirect play. Totally plausible.
ZaBeast wrote:@Sirius I'll ask again. Who do YOU trust between those? Who do YOU think is scum and who do YOU think is town? You can't forever go "we need to decide which one is scummy" without you expressing any kind of opinion on the matter
ZaBeast wrote:I think I'd be leaning slightly towards chap more than you, but I'm 60 pages away from making up my mind
ZaBeast wrote:@Sirius I'll ask again. Who do YOU trust between those? Who do YOU think is scum and who do YOU think is town? You can't forever go "we need to decide which one is scummy" without you expressing any kind of opinion on the matter
ZaBeast wrote:ZaBeast wrote:I think I'd be leaning slightly towards chap more than you, but I'm 60 pages away from making up my mind
being scum I mean
Sirius Kase wrote: I'm not trying to win an argument, I'm trying to win a game.
blacky365 wrote:Ok interesting post and obviously I would be up for this 100%
But what would happen in the very likely scenario that one of us is bussed? Or fails in the night action for whatever reason?
We have had 4 nights and I have only successfully investigated one time so I am not sure how it could turn out.
As much as I would have no problem with it, you are giving us both a free pass for the next 2 or 3 nights and I’m not sure that is a good idea for anyone
Razorvich wrote:
Sirius Kase wrote:So, I'm still focused on who do we trust between Pika and Blacky? It's not enough knowing what they can do, must know alignment, too. We should test them. I was tempted to suggest having them investigate each other, but surely one would lie and the other wouldn't, and we wouldn't have learned anything. I can see from my forum searches that Pika has been playing Mafia for years and Blacky hasn't. The ability to tell a believable lie correlates more with experience than with scumminess.
A better test would be for them to both investigate the same player, report their results, then have the investigated player make a claim or be lynched. Who to investigate? Claptrap? But that means we can't lynch him since investigations must be conducted at night. Or go ahead and lynch him, and investigate some other player of interest.
Sirius Kase wrote:ZaBeast wrote:@Sirius I'll ask again. Who do YOU trust between those? Who do YOU think is scum and who do YOU think is town? You can't forever go "we need to decide which one is scummy" without you expressing any kind of opinion on the matter
If I knew, I wouldn't have asked. I'm an engineer, not a lawyer. I rarely ask questions where I already know the answer. When I ask a question, I want to know something, and if I don't get a good answer, then I propose a test or an experiment. If there are flaws with my proposal, I don't mind modifying the plan. I'm not trying to win an argument, I'm trying to win a game.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
strike wolf wrote:It may just be because I'm having difficulty focusing and missed it but Sirius what about Pika and Blacky's claims make them mutually exclusive?
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users