Moderator: Community Team
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
strike wolf wrote:Continuing:
I think Serbia has been more active than whoever it was who said he was quiet thinks. He's not the most active but he's better than a lot (including myself) in this game. The only thing that really stood out to me about him was his position on the Tim vs Dakky argument and him reversing his position on Dakky Vs Tim. Cant quite tell if it is flip flopping or legitimate confusion on his part.
Mitch is Mitch. My position is basically the same as Hotshot's on this matter. I have no legitimate objection to the lynch but I don't really plan on pushing for it either with the information we have now.
Now someone who is not making mega posts but I feel is a bit sparse in content: Kwanton:
So out of those, I count maybe 3 with any real substance to them. So subtracting the obligatory opening joke vote makes about 50% of what he said filler. Furthermore, to fill out his impressive resume of posts, he finishes with no real conclusions drawn about anyone.
Unvote Vote Kwan
Fircoal wrote:
Let's go one by one.
@MM - Eh, what would his lynch answer? You're staying it'll provide teh most answers but what will it give us. I can see how he's suspcious but I don't think lynching him makes any more answers compared to anyone else. Also I counter that he's a good actor, but then again if he's scum he's also not the best scum either.(Sorry MM)
Talapus wrote:I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
So I think it's fair to assume based on the intro that there are at least 3 factions; Scum (Team Rocket), Town (Trainer) and 3rd party (Pokemans).
Ragian wrote:Anyoen care for my thoughts on Marashu? Also, do we have a deadline, Mandy the Mod?
BuJaber wrote:Plus of course, Talapus' case on him, makes sense to me personally... Why would he reject completely the idea that team rocket could be considered trainers? Don't they "train" pokemon?
Talapus wrote:Minister Masket wrote:Cheers for the support. I also counter-agree on Team Rocket being trainers.
Wiki disagrees with you. Plus the past roles of the characters as a pokemon coordinator for one of them and the fact they both went to a trainer type school makes this very hard for me to buy they can't be considered as trainers.
Talapus wrote:Minister Masket wrote:1) Way to ignore what my point actually was. It wasn't about their ages. It was about being associated with the Professor (Oak). The Professors have only ever given Pokemon to 'good' trainers (apart from 'rivals' like Gary Oak, but they usually turned out not so bad in the end).
And in Mandy's scene we have Oak once again sending some kids out on their way with some Pokemon. So your point about these trainers is completely nonsensical at best.
Actually, he hands out pokemon to beginning trainers starting out. Not necessarily good or evil and as you have already agreed to ideas of cult like roles being in the game than a trainer could most certainly become town or mafia aligned. On top of this fact that I have stated above the team rocket members can clearly be considered trainers as can Giovanni which Chu mentioned to you earlier in a post. So nonsensical? Not so much...but nice try.Minister Masket wrote:
2) And now you're putting words in my mouth. I literally said a few pages back that the odds of htting a scum trainer are bad because I have an inkling that there will be more town trainers than scum. Read: I have full confidence that Team Rocket are in the game and are also considered trainers. I also said I believe Gary Oak might be around, possibly as 3rd party. Now you tell me how you got "all trainers are good/town" from that?Minister Masket wrote:
Cheers for the support. I also counter-agree on Team Rocket being trainers.
Pot, meet kettle...LOL
Minister Masket wrote:I can see I've picked up a few votes, but for anyone else watching, I think Mandy's story clue here is important.
Those kid trainers are almost 100% certain to be 'town' trainers. As for Team Rocket, while yes, it's likely they'll be here, it's by no means guaranteed. Giovanni I would say is likely sitting in the 'godfather' role, but he was never really a 'trainer' per se. More like a businessman who constantly got he lackies doing his work for him.
Don't think he's been mentioned yet but Gary Oak might be here too, maybe in a 3rd party capacity.
In a nutshell, I don't believe those are good enough odds to target what you believe is a trainer. You're more likely to hit town.Minister Masket wrote:
I do not believe for a second that these trainers are going to be scum.
So...let me see if I got this right. Team rocket...not trainers. Giovanni, not a trainer. Almost 100% certain the "town" trainers are the ones professor Oak handed out the Pokemon too. Then you back it up by saying you don't believe for a second that those particular trainers are scum. Sounds to me like my arguments weren't built on lies at all...just your awful way with words and not understanding what you are saying. Because based on this you are telling us all trainers are obviously town.
Skoffin wrote:Fast posting before heading out, I'm I'm just responding to what Tal just posted now.
I don't see what you are getting at in regards to Masket's wording. As I understood it he was saying that Team rocket can be trainers (which is true), the kids Oak sent out are trainers (which is true) and trainers can have a mix of town/scum (which is assumed true). The trainers of Team Rocket have NOTHING to do with Professor Oak, therefore Professor Oak did not hand out any pokemon to any mafia team. So his comment that those kid trainers are not mafia is a fair assessment. I'm not getting where you are going with this.
Skoffin wrote: Buh? wha? fa? guh? He literally said that he thinks Team rocket are trainers. The only thing he said regarding a team rocket member NOT being a trainer was Giovanni. It's literally quoted by Talapus.
Where are people getting the notion that Masket outright rejected the idea of any trainers being bad?
Samlen wrote:Oh rip the one thing I did forget to put in here. Since Team Rocket are trainers, it'd make sense if they also were paired up with a pokemon from day1, making it easier to find them if we looked at the pool of trainer/pokemon pairings. At first I've just assumed that Team Rocket and the unknown assailant were one and the same, but thinking about it more, I'm pretty sure the unknown assailant is unrelated to team rocket. I don't remember team rocket being killers exactly, so it wouldn't make much sense if they were what sounds like a serial killer. Which means this SK is def a problem to worry about, but we don't really have a concrete way to find them yet. Team Rocket, if my theory is correct, could be found a bit more easily.
Skoffin wrote:Ragian wrote:Anyoen care for my thoughts on Marashu? Also, do we have a deadline, Mandy the Mod?
Why are you asking us if we want to hear it? Why not just... say it?
madmitch wrote:I believe Tim is a trainer for Team Rocket and since legion seems to be protecting him he must be one of tims pokemons.
- (fixed the quote)madmitch wrote:legionnare wrote:@Wing, care to qualify your case on Tim? I'm not seeing anything particularly scummy
@Legion ,it was this statement that caught my EYE
Anarkistsdream wrote:So, even though you have put MINIMAL effort into this game, you think I should think back 5-9 years ago to the games I played with these people and analyze each player? First, piss off. Second, I have had far too much bourbon, have moved too many times, have changed jobs a few, and have had far too many life experiences to actually remember that... That guy you ate with at work for years, what did he eat everyday? That is basically what you are asking of me, and that is patently absurd. After this long, most people are not going to play the exact same way anyway. We have all grown, and a few of us have even matured... To try and meta that is a waste of my time. But next time you ask me to spend hours on one post just to assuage your fears, do me a favor and right more than two or three sentences at a time.
Ragian wrote:
Also, who is chu?
legionnare wrote:Perhaps I mis-worded my question; my intent was not to suggest that you spend hours analyzing each player, merely that if you had any experience of playing with Minister Masket and madmitch (the current lynch candidates) and if you did then in general how do feel about their playstyle in this game in comparison to others.
virus90 wrote: I think Anarkist is a valuable asset to any game.
Ragian wrote:Now, back to Marashu: Apparently, he war 3rd party last game. This game, I get a similar vibe from him. To me, it seems that he limits his posts to flavour discussion and necessary comments on already revealed back-and-forths between the players rather than contributing and voting. For that, I'll vote Marashu
Marashu wrote:I find this mitchwagon interesting - Tim and mitch are both rather erratic players, but it was interesting that there seemed to be a bit of resistance to the case on Tim, while mitch has had 4 votes in the last 3 hours. That said, I'm usually ok with either of them being lynched D1 and this is no exception.
legionnare wrote:@Anark, my thanks. As I said, I'm not too experienced so trying shift my playstyle to fit a non-standard set up is...difficult. (Talk about throwing myself into the deep end when I decided to give Mafia another go)
virus90 wrote: I think Anarkist is a valuable asset to any game.
WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:@Dakky, and I told Mandy to wall me if he wanted me to sub, and he didnt, so why should I obey his rules. I genuinely want to know who Spurg is as I have failed to see a single post by him. Did he even confirm?
TimWoodbury wrote:so after reading through its been mentioned that there is a good possability that the trainers/pokemon pair know each other and chances of them being cult recruiters. this id have to say makes since.
so heres what were looking at right now for teams/groups
team rocket
trainer/pokemon pair
wild pokemon
now 1 crazy out there thought im gonna throw in where we have 20 some odd people we know gary is most likley in the game wich means ash is prolly in it, whats there long term goal other then catching them all...defeating the elite 4... im thinking the elite 4 are also in the game.
with that said i meant to do this a while ago unvote vote Anarkistsdream with the slip up a few pages ago saying we instead of they and other things he aint sitting right.
as others have said mitch is THE wildcard he can be good or bad and say stupid stuff and get himself killed early on his more better info seems to come on the few games where he dont kill himself early on so lets keep him alive a couple of days
dakky21 wrote:WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:@Dakky, and I told Mandy to wall me if he wanted me to sub, and he didnt, so why should I obey his rules. I genuinely want to know who Spurg is as I have failed to see a single post by him. Did he even confirm?
Link to all Spurgistan's posts here
If you failed to see his posts, you were skimming. Not accusing you right now as 7 posts in 19 pages can be easily missed, but I think he should be replaced. Though he did stick by the rules, one post per 3 days though.
new guy1 wrote:So you're not giving any thought to the idea that team rocket may have pokemon which count as a separate entity/paired entity? You went to the trouble to separate trainer and pokemon pair, but didn't bother to separate the antagonists from their possible pokemon (which has been talked about more than once and mentioned in your next post, it should be on the forefront of your mind). What is your stance on that theory, since you seem to have eliminated it here? Or must have forgotten it when you made this post. Elite 4 is not Indigo league that I know of and is quite a stretch for even being in this game. How do you think they would play into the game, provided they're in it, since above, you seem to imply that they would have to be defeated by the trainers? If this isn't how you meant it, then please explain your stance in more depth.
madmitch wrote:I will try to explain my last post,there was the Dakky AND Tim conversation about Team Rocket then tim backed away like he was hiding something, a MEMBER OF TEAM ROCKET?. MM soft claimed trainer ,but I believe he is good, there is a connection between WCG and NARK ,I am not sure really who is trainer and pokemon, also there is a connection between Doom and SKITTLES same problem who is who ? Samlen makes a lot of comments but has not really commited to anything almost like he is running wild
and Exile said he didn't like trainers so he must be a pokemon, That is what I am thinking but I could be completely wrong.
KraphtOne wrote:when you sign up a new account one of the check boxes should be "do you want to foe colton24 (it is highly recommended) "
Ragian wrote:Samlen wrote:Oh rip the one thing I did forget to put in here. Since Team Rocket are trainers, it'd make sense if they also were paired up with a pokemon from day1, making it easier to find them if we looked at the pool of trainer/pokemon pairings. At first I've just assumed that Team Rocket and the unknown assailant were one and the same, but thinking about it more, I'm pretty sure the unknown assailant is unrelated to team rocket. I don't remember team rocket being killers exactly, so it wouldn't make much sense if they were what sounds like a serial killer. Which means this SK is def a problem to worry about, but we don't really have a concrete way to find them yet. Team Rocket, if my theory is correct, could be found a bit more easily.
I'm not sure what you mean by "rip". It wasn't too important for context, though. I agree that if an SK is loose, we can't say exactly who it is at this point, but it defo stresses the importance of looking at strange/scummy behaviour. Now, how exactly does it work looking at the pool of trainer/pokemon pairs that you mention? Are you privy to information about such pairings or are you just airing this as the way to go if we gain such knowledge? That's why you're saying "theory", right?
DoomYoshi wrote:
In all seriousness though, I am willing to bet that Masket isn't even a trainer. He's a pokemon willing to sacrifice himself so that his trainer can find all the other trainers. His posts have just been to sow confusion. That confusion reaping is enough to make him the D1 kill IMO. Not that there is a better D1 case. Mitch is convincing but the same case could be made every D1 against him. Give me a couple days to read him and I will tell if he is scum or not (My reads on him are 2/2 or 100%).
Skoffin wrote:Fast posting before heading out, I'm I'm just responding to what Tal just posted now.
I don't see what you are getting at in regards to Masket's wording. As I understood it he was saying that Team rocket can be trainers (which is true), the kids Oak sent out are trainers (which is true) and trainers can have a mix of town/scum (which is assumed true). The trainers of Team Rocket have NOTHING to do with Professor Oak, therefore Professor Oak did not hand out any pokemon to any mafia team. So his comment that those kid trainers are not mafia is a fair assessment. I'm not getting where you are going with this.
Samlen wrote:The only thing making me question that Team Rocket have starting pokemon is skoffin's quote, which makes sense now that I think about it since I don't remember Prof Oak ever affiliating with Team Rocket... so I guess that makes this theory useless unless people want to hunt down other trainers :S
KraphtOne wrote:when you sign up a new account one of the check boxes should be "do you want to foe colton24 (it is highly recommended) "
new guy1 wrote:After reading, there's just one post that stood out as off putting to me (a lot of it was just the same setup discussions we have had, etc.):TimWoodbury wrote:so after reading through its been mentioned that there is a good possability that the trainers/pokemon pair know each other and chances of them being cult recruiters. this id have to say makes since.
so heres what were looking at right now for teams/groups
team rocket
trainer/pokemon pair
wild pokemon
now 1 crazy out there thought im gonna throw in where we have 20 some odd people we know gary is most likley in the game wich means ash is prolly in it, whats there long term goal other then catching them all...defeating the elite 4... im thinking the elite 4 are also in the game.
with that said i meant to do this a while ago unvote vote Anarkistsdream with the slip up a few pages ago saying we instead of they and other things he aint sitting right.
as others have said mitch is THE wildcard he can be good or bad and say stupid stuff and get himself killed early on his more better info seems to come on the few games where he dont kill himself early on so lets keep him alive a couple of days
So you're not giving any thought to the idea that team rocket may have pokemon which count as a separate entity/paired entity? You went to the trouble to separate trainer and pokemon pair, but didn't bother to separate the antagonists from their possible pokemon (which has been talked about more than once and mentioned in your next post, it should be on the forefront of your mind). What is your stance on that theory, since you seem to have eliminated it here? Or must have forgotten it when you made this post. Elite 4 is not Indigo league that I know of and is quite a stretch for even being in this game. How do you think they would play into the game, provided they're in it, since above, you seem to imply that they would have to be defeated by the trainers? If this isn't how you meant it, then please explain your stance in more depth.
Ragian wrote:
*notes Hotshot accusing others of inactivity*
Talapus wrote:I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
Talapus wrote:I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users