aage wrote:Why does Greg show as Chaot/Evil in your sheet?
All in all mafia was on one hand kinda lucky, on the other very strongly positioned. It was obvious that the Chaots and the Lawfuls didn't want to cooperate with town, even though I urged numerous times that they would, since they were too obsessed with rooting out their counterparts. This allowed the mafia to easily swoop in and snatch victory, despite Rish's mistakes. Commander was the most expendable member of the mafia team role-wise, so he was the best worst case scenario for an early loss. After cult went down, it seemed nobody gave a damn about finding scum any more. In hindsight it's only logical because two thirds of the good/neutral players were dead by that point already.
Despite that, I think this was an awesome game. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Don't look at me. I actually tried to support your viewpoint early on, it was mostly Doomyoshi that kept driving the wedge. Of course, Jonty fake claiming lawful did not help.
Epitaph1 wrote:I really enjoyed this game. The alignments made for a lot more gamesmanship than the typical town v. mafia setup. When Rodion made his pitch at the end, I was surprised how quickly players agreed to his offer--but that's what the various alignments allowed.
jonty fakeclaiming at the beginning set the tone that the chaotic was not a desirable alignment. That made the mafia's lives easier since it drove a wedge between the town.
I thought SW was N/N prior to his claim.
After the recruiter was killed (I had no idea Neb was the recruiter btw), it was funny to see a lot of people dismiss the existence of the janitor. Rish almost seemed indignant that people weren't giving the janitor credit anymore.
I also laughed out loud when MoB got silenced and then everyone agreed to lynch him at the end. Rough day for him.
I'd give Rodion MVP if we go that direction. But I'm not opposed to giving out premiums to the winners.
Yeah. I had figured Rish was mafia but his janitor arguments...I really thought he was not the janitor even if there was one.
Well I was going for somewhere around g/n to n/n so I guess that works out.
I could agree with Rodion getting the MVP if we go with one person. He contributed as much to the win as anyone. Though I have to say that you and Spiesr (for what little time he was in the game) played your parts well too. Doctor was a good claim though admittedly you were still pretty high up on my lynch list after Rodion. The end of the day when you did come out with being Evil/Lawful openly, sealed in my mind that Rodion was telling the truth about both of you being lawful. Still...
*Silences all living evil neutrals for lying and breaking vows. YOU MUST OBEY THE LAW!*
One question about TFO's Role. So he had unlimited bulletproofs?