I admit some of the claims are suspicious but none of them are suspicious enough to earn a lynch. They are claimed power roles and could be very useful so we don't want to get rid of them. Plus the cults will be fearful of recruiting them in case they fail or die meaning the pool of players for them to choose from is reduced.
If you really want to lynch a claimed power role then I suggest getting mpjh to investigate them first.
I find it suspicious that people are wanting these power roles lynched without good reason.
p.s. I like the level of activity in this game from some players but others are completely silent, i hope some of the newer people stick around.
2009-08-12 03:35:31 - Squirrels Hat: MWAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!! 2009-08-12 03:44:25 - Mr. Squirrel: Do you think my hat will attack me?
william18 wrote:Firstly kagetora(sp?) claimed a cult hunter, but not what cult. Pretty good scum claim. Cult hunters can't counter-claim since they don't know what he's hunting, and I doubt they will all reveal themselves just for this purpose.
There could be no such thing as cult hunters and it be entirely a fake claim, so no one would know to counter.
mpjh wrote:I have a different power each night. I investigated last night.
I suggest again that we pick someone who never posts substantive discussion and vote to lynch. I think that is a likely as any method to get to the "silent" cult leaders.
mpjh wrote:I have a different power each night. I investigated last night.
I suggest again that we pick someone who never posts substantive discussion and vote to lynch. I think that is a likely as any method to get to the "silent" cult leaders.
Oh so your a JOAT? (Jack Of All Trades).
Why not? unvote vote drench
p.s. This time we need to vote for the same person to increase pressure.
2009-08-12 03:35:31 - Squirrels Hat: MWAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!! 2009-08-12 03:44:25 - Mr. Squirrel: Do you think my hat will attack me?
mpjh wrote:I have a different power each night. I investigated last night. I suggest again that we pick someone who never posts substantive discussion and vote to lynch. I think that is a likely as any method to get to the "silent" cult leaders.
Oh so your a JOAT? (Jack Of All Trades).
No, I am pretty sure me means he gets a random power each night.
Correct, I've said absolutely nowt, apologies for that... Probably going to get me swiftly bandwagoned and in a certain respect rightly so.
Ace investigated me most likely because believe it or not I am the most experienced mafia player in this game and have been playing longer than all the rest of you , having started playing mafia on this website back in april 2007 when mafia games were next to all other forum threads. I haven't been playing much mafia recently like in the old days where I was a lot more active but Natewolfman personally invited me to this game, and I decided not to decline. Maybe I should have considering my activity has been less than satisfactory and once again I apologise for that.
captainwalrus wrote:unvote (if i havn't already) Vote nagerous I want him to talk more, to see if he and ace are cultists in cahoots. I think that nagerous was recruted by ace and then ace made up that role to protect his new cult leader. Also nagerous hasn't said anything yet so I wonder why ace would have investigated him.
Your logic is unsound, why would ace recruit me then claim that I was not the red cult leader in order to clear me. Wouldn't that put ace, the supposed cult leader in danger himself with such a crazy far fetched plan. Also, if we were in cahoots wouldn't he clear me from being in all three cults, not just one... seems rather illogical to me.
nagerous wrote:Correct, I've said absolutely nowt, apologies for that... Probably going to get me swiftly bandwagoned and in a certain respect rightly so.
Ace investigated me most likely because believe it or not I am the most experienced mafia player in this game and have been playing longer than all the rest of you , having started playing mafia on this website back in april 2007 when mafia games were next to all other forum threads. I haven't been playing much mafia recently like in the old days where I was a lot more active but Natewolfman personally invited me to this game, and I decided not to decline. Maybe I should have considering my activity has been less than satisfactory and once again I apologise for that.
Stop showing off and living in the past and contribute to the game!
Only jokin, you, ga7 and a few others seem about the only ones left from the old crew, soon me and ani will be the most experienced players here
2009-08-12 03:35:31 - Squirrels Hat: MWAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!! 2009-08-12 03:44:25 - Mr. Squirrel: Do you think my hat will attack me?
captainwalrus wrote:unvote (if i havn't already) Vote nagerous I want him to talk more, to see if he and ace are cultists in cahoots. I think that nagerous was recruted by ace and then ace made up that role to protect his new cult leader. Also nagerous hasn't said anything yet so I wonder why ace would have investigated him.
Your logic is unsound, why would ace recruit me then claim that I was not the red cult leader in order to clear me. Wouldn't that put ace, the supposed cult leader in danger himself with such a crazy far fetched plan. Also, if we were in cahoots wouldn't he clear me from being in all three cults, not just one... seems rather illogical to me.
I don't see how it is that far fetched of a plan. It is clearly working. It is just suspicious that he claimed his role by declaring you not the red leader. Which brings me to my next point, why wouldn't he clear you from all cults? Because that is a far fetched role. But kage had just claimed a similar role so he jumped on and said you weren't red.
captainwalrus wrote:I don't see how it is that far fetched of a plan. It is clearly working. It is just suspicious that he claimed his role by declaring you not the red leader. Which brings me to my next point, why wouldn't he clear you from all cults? Because that is a far fetched role. But kage had just claimed a similar role so he jumped on and said you weren't red.
Assuming that kangaroo was telling the truth it would be a horrible idea for ace to try to fake claim that as there would surely be someone the counter it. It is possible he would luck out and that person would be too inactive to counter him but it would not be worth the risk.
I disagree with the no lynch. Lynching still seems like the best way to get some information IMO. As to whom to lynch, i really have no idea. Nobody seems overly suspicious yet.
I'd really like kage to let us know what's with calling ace a liar and trying to contact him privately, though.
Highest score: 3063; Highest position: 67; Winner of {World War II tournament, -team 2010 Skilled Diversity, [FuN||Chewy]-[XII] USA}; 8-3-7
mpjh wrote:OK, this town is going no where fast. I suggest we do not lynch anyone today and go into the night.
This is the second time Mpjh has pushed for a no lynch. On top of that he claims he cannot be recruited by cults. Going with the theme of 3 I doubt he has such a role. I don't have time to pull up a big case against him. Unvote vote mpjh
I AM MASTER SHEEP, TEH AWESOME
DoomYoshi wrote:Test it on me. Tree stump is my favorite role anyway lol. Next time I am picking Wispy Woods as my character.
mpjh wrote:OK, this town is going no where fast. I suggest we do not lynch anyone today and go into the night.
This is the second time Mpjh has pushed for a no lynch. On top of that he claims he cannot be recruited by cults. Going with the theme of 3 I doubt he has such a role. I don't have time to pull up a big case against him. Unvote vote mpjh
I AM MASTER SHEEP, TEH AWESOME
DoomYoshi wrote:Test it on me. Tree stump is my favorite role anyway lol. Next time I am picking Wispy Woods as my character.
Question about the mpjh voters. Do you intend to drive this vote all the way to a lynch? He has already claimed so there is no more info to get out of him.
, having started playing mafia on this website back in april 2007 when mafia games were next to all other forum threads. I haven't been playing much mafia recently like in the old days where I was a lot more active but Natewolfman personally invited me to this game, and I decided not to decline. Maybe I should have considering my activity has been less than satisfactory and once again I apologise for that.
